First half_1, Columbus, Mokhtar, 0 (Valenzuela), 18th minute.
Second half_None.
Goalies_Columbus, Andrew Tarbell, Matt Lampson; Atlanta, Brad Guzan, reduslim Alec Kann, Brendan Moore.
Yellow Cards_Valenzuela, Columbus, 25th; Escobar, Atlanta, 45th+4; Santos, Columbus, 60th; Robinson, Atlanta, 73rd; Jimenez, Columbus, 85th; Diaz, Columbus, 90th+3.
Referee_Tim Ford.
Assistant Referees_Andrew Bigelow, Jason White, Dave Gantar. 4th Official_Allen Chapman.
___
Columbus_Andrew Tarbell; Harrison Afful, Aboubacar Keita, Jonathan Mensah, Milton Valenzuela (Hector Jimenez, 46th); Artur, Luis Diaz, Youness Mokhtar (Derrick Etienne, 44th), Darlington Nagbe (Sebastian Berhalter, 80th), Pedro Santos (Lucas Zelarrayan, 61st); Gyasi Zardes (Fanendo Adi, 60th).
Atlanta_Brad Guzan; George Bello (Manuel Castro, 69th), Franco Escobar (Anton Walkes, 72nd), Fernando Meza (Eric Remedi, 45th), Miles Robinson; Mo Adams, Ezequiel Barco, Emerson Hyndman (Jeff Larentowicz, 80th), Gonzalo Martinez; Adam Jahn (Jon Gallagher, 46th), Brooks Lennon.